Sustainable Heritage-Sensitive Addition and Renovation
This recent addition and renovation to a Heritage Peterborough home is constructed almost entirely of local and/or renewable materials and is loaded with sustainable features including solar thermal panels, a grid-connected solar electric system and trenched geothermal heating.
The original house was built across the street from Little Lake in 1862. It was the first severance to the 100 acre allotment owned by Rev. R.S. Burnham and was the first house built on Maria St in Peterborough. "It was very important that the addition respected the original flavour of the house", says client Simon Boone, who recently pursued Heritage Designation for this nearly 150 year old home. The gingerbread details on the front porch, likely added in the 1900s, and the stacked wood construction method of the original house are historically significant in the area.

Because the house was so small, 700 SF, it was important the new addition, 1200 SF, did not visually dwarf the original house. The workshop to the east of the house was placed on the lot to allow for this addition. The roof lines of the new addition reflect both the lines of the original front porch as well as the dormer on the workshop.
Like the original house, the addition is timber construction built with locally harvested and milled White Pine. Diagonal braces are reclaimed Douglas fir, salvaged from a Prince Edward County industrial building that was being demolished. The floors are milled locally from local White Pine and Butternut.

Local and/or eco-sensitive building materials were used everywhere possible throughout the construction. Some of these materials include structurally insulated panel footings and roof structure, plastered and compressed earthblocks for interior walls, locally produced eco-sensitive spray foam insulation, and a vented, reflective steel roof. All of these help to enhance the thermal performance of the building and also have a low environmental impact. The cove siding is harvested and milled locally to match the siding of the original house.
Radiant floor heat was installed throughout the entire main floor and basement of addition. Water radiators were installed in upper level of addition as well as retrofitted to original house. The finished interior has a seamless floor height throughout entire house, across wood, concrete, and tile flooring.
Radiators and radiant floor are fed by a 3 ton geothermal unit with a trenched ground loop containing 1800' of piping. The thermal mass in the house - timbers, earthblocks, concrete, and tile - helps buffer seasonal humidity and absorbs natural heat from the sun. This allows the geothermal unit to run much more efficiently, operating at only 110F. The unit also has a de-superheater to generate domestic hot water. The ground loop is made up of 3 x 300' trenches, each 6' deep and 2' wide. With some creative digging it was possible to squeeze all 1800' of pipe in the 75' x 100' backyard.

The addition has a rooftop solar thermal system that, in combination with the geothermal system, supplies all of the hot water to the house throughout the year. It also has a battery-less solar electric system that directly supplies the hydro grid energy at a premium rate through the province's microFIT program. "We generate enough revenue from the sale of electricity to pay for the hydro and water that our home consumes," says Mr. Boone. Thus, the house has no need for natural gas or oil. It provides more clean energy than the energy it consumes.
This heritage sensitive, sustainable addition blends seamlessly with the original house and workshop. It is built almost entirely from local, eco-sensitive materials, and produces more energy than it consumes!
Key sustainable features include the following:
locally harvested and milled White Pine timber construction
reclaimed Douglas fir from demolished building used as diagonal bracing
locally harvested and milled hard wood flooring and exterior cove siding
Structurally Insulated Panel footings and roof structure
vented and reflective, long-lasting, recyclable steel roof
earthblock construction for interior walls
eco-sensitive, locally produced spray foam insulation
passive solar design with south facing thermally-glazed windows adjacent to thermal mass
geothermal heating system that feeds radiant floor heating and radiators retrofitted to original house. Combined with passive solar, the geothermal system provides all the heating for the home.
rooftop solar thermal system, in combination with geothermal de-superheater, provides all the hot water for the home.
rooftop battery-less solar panels are connected directly to the grid and generate more clean energy than the house consumes.
Take 2 minutes and check out the archiTEXT /sustainable.TO Community Design Initiative project:
From The Community Animator - Toronto East - September 2010
The East Scarborough Storefront is an exciting example of how community work is helping a neighbourhood . This past week Anne Gloger, the Storefront Director, gave us some background on ESS's involvement with the community and on their green focus:
"The East Scarborough Storefront, in true community fashion, is drawing on the skills, ideas and knowledge of local residents and agency partners to create an "eco food centre" as part of its hub expansion.
The Storefront "hub" has been facilitating the work of agencies and residents in the priority neighbourhood of Kingston Galloway Orton Park(KGO) for almost 10 years. It's real strength is listening to the community and developing structures to support their ideas. In one recent "Community Speak" ideas to turn the Storefront facility at 4040 Lawrence (formerly a police substation) into a large, accessible and green community resource centre came through loud and clear. In another, residents lead discussions on developing innovative community lead food access initatives.
It was the voices of residents at these two events that inspired the Storefront to facilitate a discussion with its partners and supporters including: Live Green Toronto, the Metcalf Foundation, Schools Without Borders, Westhill Community Service, Evergreen, archiTEXT and sustainable.TO. These discussions lead to a concept for an fabulous "eco-food" project which will create the foundation for all sorts of community based environmental and food initiatives. We look forward to future announcements of Storefront's grey-water system, resident food based-businesses and eco learning opportunities ... we're doing it all based on resident's ideas, and, of course, in true Storefront fashion, the eco-food centre is being designed by local youth."
sustainable.TO is a small band of young (and young-at-heart), sustainably-minded, architecturally-creative individuals led by Paul Dowsett - Architect, OAA, MRAIC, LEED(TM) AP.
We provide sensible, sensitive & sustainable design & construction services for residential, commercial and institutional environments.
It has been our pleasure to work with archiTEXT and the youth of East Scarborough in a mentorship capacity to help them to develop and design the alterations to their Storefront.
As we continue in this role, we are also looking forward to providing professional architectural services to the Storefront for the realization of their multi-phased revitalization projects, not least of which are the connections from garden, to kitchen, to table, and back to garden --
the eco-food project.
From Anne Gloger:
THE VISION
Residents and agencies in Kingston Galloway Orton Park (KGO) share a broad vision of creating and supporting a thriving inner suburban neighbourhood.
The KGO neighbourhood is best known for its gang violence and motel strip. The East Scarborough Storefront envisions the KGO neighbourhood instead becoming a model for how to develop and support grassroots eco-sustainability and food security in an inner suburban neighbourhood. We envision a community space that facilitates resident leadership in developing food security strategy, eco education, and economic opportunity for some of the city's most marginalized ...and we envision doing it, as we do everything in KGO, in collaboration.
THE ORGANIZATION
The East Scarborough Storefront operates under an innovative and collaborative model, known throughout Toronto and beyond for its creative and successful approach to community development in the inner suburbs. It has initiated or supported projects like the Neighbourhood Trust, Community Garden, Business Resource Centre, Community Speaks, and Community Design Initiative.
By nurturing diversity and collaboration and exploring possibilities within the community, we are a catalyst for neighbourhood renewal. Inner suburbs like KGO are an important part of our city. Though often neglected or dismissed, the inner suburbs are rich with untapped potential. For the past 10 years Storefront has facilitated the work of dozens of agencies and hundreds of residents to build on this community's remarkable strengths and to celebrate a passionate community with hopes and plans for the future.
THE PROJECT
The Eco-food Project enables Storefront to establish an eco-food hub which will rest within our already thriving service-delivery hub, and will act as a foundation and catalyst for a myriad of environmental and food-focused initiatives.
The eco-food hub is designed as a creative and practical space that acts as a nucleus for a diversity of food and "green" activity for an entire community. Through the eco-food hub, agencies and residents will share their knowledge and expertise on healthy cooking and eating, environmentally sound practices, and caring for the community. The hub will also support budding entrepreneurs as they test new ideas, cook for local groups, and gain necessary training and certification to realize their dreams.
The eco-food hub will be a place that nurtures the spirit of collaboration around food and green initiatives in an "at risk" neighbourhood. It will be a place that demonstrates the capacity of people living in poverty, people marginalized and often isolated in the inner suburbs, to be leaders in connecting to the earth, our food, and each other.
The eco-food hub is a vital component of Storefront's larger project of reclaiming an old police station and turning it into vibrant community space.
THE SPECIFICS
The core of the eco-food centre will act as a catalyst for a wide variety and diversity of programming and initiatives by a large number of groups and organizations. Specifically, we propose:
A versatile and accessible commercial grade kitchen with capacity for a wide range of programs:
Demolition of two former offices to create a large kitchen space in the eastern part of the building, right next to the community garden
Stainless steel work surfaces on wheels that that they can be configured in ways that meet the needs of a wide variety of groups
Dedicated workspace that is completely wheel chair accessible
Commercial grade cooler
Walk in freezer and pantry
Gas powered professional range
Appropriate commercial venting
Industrial dishwashing facilities
Connect kitchen programs and activities to already existing infrastructure like the community garden and composting
Three step composting system
Composting education for Storefront's staff 35 partners and 50 in house volunteers
New garden plots to grow food specifically for cooking opportunities and demonstrations
Create new infrastructure like rainwater management and irrigation that will link directly with activities taking place in the kitchen and the garden
Cistern irrigation system
Rainwater management and usage education for Storefront's staff, 35 partners and 50 in house volunteers
Connect indoor space with outdoor space
Roll up door from kitchen onto green space
Built in outdoor seating
Demonstration garden
Mentor local youth in the architecture and design of an effective and creative eco-food centre
Architects with sustainable.TO, interior designers, landscapers, garden specialists,
environmentalists teaching local youth ages 10-20 the art, craft and technical aspects of eco-friendly design
Make the project a catalyst and template for other inner suburban neighbourhoods investing in social and physical infrastructure
Documentation of the process that lead to the development and creation of local eco-food infrastructure using film and written word
The East Scarborough Storefront Eco-food Hub
CONNECTING TO BROADER INITIATIVES
One of the true successes of the Storefront model is that it attracts organizations and individuals who seek to connect movements to resolve systemic issues to meaningful on-the-ground experience. An example of this kind of connection is evident in our work with ERA Architects who were the instigators of the city-wide Tower Neighbourhood Renewal strategy. ERA considers the approach that Storefront takes in engaging residents in the development both of initiatives and capital developments to be an example of how to effectively develop Tower Neighbourhood Renewal. They are currently looking at integrating our processes into a province-wide initiative. The eco-food centre will serve as a tangible example to the province and beyond of the potential of community engagement and investment. The eco-food centre in and of itself is also designed to connect the work of KGO with broader movements. With key partners such as Schools Without Borders, Live Green Toronto and Evergreen, the intent is to bring City and Province-wide initiatives in a meaningful way to the local community.
THE KEY PLAYERS
Storefront Leaders
Anne Gloger
has been with the Storefront through each stage of its development. In her role as Director, Anne has facilitated the development of the Storefront model as well as much of the collaborative neighbourhood strategies evident in KGO today. Anne's background is in community and partnership development. She has a degree in Social Development and a Business Diploma. Anne is dedicated to working collaboratively, engaging in good process, and seeing the residents and businesses of KGO thrive.
Jaime Elliott Ngugi
has been working with Storefront for over four years. As Special Project Co-ordinator, Jaime's role is to ensure that projects like the eco-food centre are carried out with integrity and authentic community involvement, and in a truly collaborative spirit. Jaime is currently facilitating the architecture and youth mentorship project, as well as supporting the neighbourhood-wide Safety Initiative and the creation of a Business Resource Centre.
Architectural Partner
sustainable.TO, led by Paul Dowsett - Architect, OAA, MRAIC, LEED(TM) AP.
Agency Partners - providing leadership and connecting to broader food and environmental movements:
Seed to Table, a project of Schools Without Borders, is a youth-centered program that works to bring cooking, gardening and food education to young people. They act as a platform for addressing food security in the neighbourhood through practical, integrated approaches. These include their core programming for children and youth which explore food, growing and identity through creative and media arts; a catering social enterprise for youth seeking sustainable employment; mobile kitchens for customized community workshops; and supporting food animation throughout the community. Seed to Table is a young program that is growing with the strengths and needs of Kingston-Galloway/Orton Park. They will benefit from having an improved space for current programming, but will also expand their capacity through a long-term commitment to creating authentic space for youth leadership in the food movement.
Evergreen
is a not-for-profit organization that makes cities more liveable by connecting people and nature and empowering Canadians to take a hands-on approach to their urban environments. Evergreen has been an active partner with KGO for past 3 years. They have assisted with beautification projects including R.O.S.E. garden, tree plantings at the Morningside Park and KGO Community Clean Up Days. They are also a major partner for our SUBtext festival.
Lori Metcalfe
is a health promoter specializing in food security at the Scarborough Centre for Healthy Communities (formerly West Hill Community Services) and a long time member of the Storefront Steering Committee. Lori has been collaborating with residents and community partners over the past year to develop and implement a successful food strategy in south Scarborough. The local food strategy includes the development of a food hub/centre to create and coordinate effective food programming in Scarborough.
Katie Fullerton
from Eco Spark (formerly Citizens' Environment Watch), is the Core Animator for the Live Green Toronto program in Scarborough. Live Green Toronto is a City of Toronto program to engage communities wishing to take action to green their neighbourhoods. The goal is to help make Toronto's air cleaner, its neighbourhoods greener, and to encourage residents to do their part in addressing climate change and its effects. The Live Green Program provides the tools, resources, information, experts and funding needed to help residents develop local green initiatives that will reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Documentation Partners
archiTEXT
is a think tank focused on architecture and innovation that explores the intersection of architecture on all levels - from food to fashion to politics - and uses creative mechanisms. archTEXT has been working with the Storefront in exploring the intersection between architecture and poverty. In this role archiTEXT staff, and especially their principal, Zahra Ebrahim, have been chronicling what happens when you connect youth living in poverty with design professionals to expand community space in a "priority" neighbourhood. archTEXT is committed to chronicling the process of all aspects of the Storefront building expansion, including, and especially, the development of the eco-food centre.
Gallery
The Community. Design. Initiative. is an innovative partnership project focused around using the power of architecture and design together with place-based poverty reduction to engage youth in one of Toronto's most challenged neighborhoods. The project brings together a dynamic range of people - ones that generally would not work together in this manner - in order to create beautiful architecture for a community where it is absent.
Family finds sun, wind and straw are a recipe for success
Originally published in the Globe and Mail on April 22, 2006
In a house with an entire wall of windows reaching up 17 feet, it's the little 12" by 14" one in the foyer that's most intriguing.
Appropriately called the "truth window," it offers a tantalising peek at the guts of Glen Hunter and Joanne Sokolowski's house, which they built themselves in 2002: A golden tangle of straw, held tight with red binder and hemmed in by black plastic chicken-wire.
The window is there for many reasons. It's a great conversation-piece for first time visitors who know nothing about straw-bale houses; it reminds the couple of days spent with family and friends stacking and stitching the 400 bales that form three walls of their open-concept 2500 square foot post-and-beam home southeast of Peterborough and, lastly; it's an important reminder that things aren't always what they seem.
For instance, you'd never know the Hunter-Sokolowski family live in a house that's completely self-sufficient, one of about 1000 in the province that don't rely on the power-grid for electricity.
"We strongly feel you shouldn't live in a place like this and have to do without," Mr. Hunter explains, standing beside an outlet sprouting cell-phone chargers in a kitchen filled with the usual appliances as if to illustrate his point. "We're not trying to go back to nature; this is a modern home, we have all the modern conveniences, the only major appliance we don't have is a clothes-dryer."
Like a lot of other things around here, clothes get dry via solar-power--swinging on the line outside in summer and strung across "the gallery" right in front of all those big southern-facing windows in winter.
Mr. Hunter loves his windows. Sure, they cost $55,000, but they offer breathtaking views of his 100 acres and, more importantly, let in great gobs of precious sunlight, which form the "passive" part of his heating system. Sometimes, his radiant concrete-slab floor has soaked up enough of the sun's rays during the daytime it doesn't even switch on at night.
While Mr. Hunter's convictions for moving off-grid are as big as his window-wall, humility keeps his preaching down to "truth window" size. "I try to stay away from moral arguments about why we did any of this stuff," he says. "We don't want to be the kind of people that say 'Thou shalt build in this way.'"
August 2003's infamous blackout wasn't what drove Mr. Hunter from Toronto's Riverdale to a life spent monitoring the energy input of solar panels and a wind-turbine; when the lights went out he and his wife had already been ensconced in the Kawarthas for three months. A self-proclaimed technophile, he'd always been interested in off-grid living and, armed with a lifetime of building experience with his father, home construction didn't faze him either. So, they hired an architect to get the ball rolling.
When they didn't get what they wanted, they fired the architect.
Then, the couple ran into another architect while dog-walking, neighbour Paul Dowsett, and asked for his recommendation. Although he'd never done an off-grid home before, Mr. Dowsett (of Scott Morris Architects) came back a few days later with a plan so stunning they hired him on the spot. "We are now the first of, I think three, off-grid environmentally-sensitive homes he's done," beams Mr. Hunter.
And what a home he's created for Hunter, Sokolowski, 18-month old Gil and the baby that's expected this autumn. Sitting in the bright and spacious living area under the soaring segmented roof held aloft by Paralam beams, Mr. Hunter, ironically sporting a Pickering Nuclear Generating Station work-shirt, talks choreography. For his home, that is. His office area will become a bedroom for Gil when the new baby takes over the nursery off the master bedroom--one, two--when the new baby needs a separate room, they'll borrow a little more square footage from the living area and subdivide Gil's room--three, four--the nursery, with plumbing already roughed-in, will then become a parental ensuite--five, six, seven, eight--in 20 years, when the kids have grown up, the walls will come down, again opening up the space that's "designed to hold a pool table," he chuckles. "We built a 100-year house, not a 20-year tract home."
Time Mr. Hunter will spend, no doubt, perfecting the amazing low-wattage LED light fixtures he's developed for the house (available at Eurolite), the inspiration for which came, like most great inventions, from a simple need: Driving home during pitch-black country nights, the couple needed to "find the house" by leaving a few lights on without sucking too much power from their energy storage-tank. They also wanted ambient lighting during late-night television sessions so they could get to the bathroom "without tripping over a dog or hitting a shin on something" so shaft and borealis were born.
Mr. Hunter is full of bright ideas. Now if the rest of us would just lighten up a little and slap a few solar panels on the roof, we'd really be opening a window onto a new world.
Since the initial House was built, Paul Dowsett and his firm were retained to design a complementary Work/Storage Shed, using as many materials salvaged from the first house as possible.
Currently, Paul and sustainable.to are assisting with the design of a new Sugar Shack & Truck Maintenance Shed, nestled into the original barn foundations.
This contemporary, passive-solar, off-grid, straw bale house uses the latest technology to transform natural elements into power, and some very basic, common-sense planning and material choices to hold onto that energy once it is stored.
Architect: Scott Morris Architects Inc.
Principal in Charge: Paul Dowsett, Architect
This rural, environmentally-sensitive home incorporates numerous sustainable features, including:
passive solar design with south-facing, thermally-glazed, top-vented gallery, shaded to reduce summertime solar heat gain;
roof-mounted solar electric (photo-voltaic) and solar water heating systems;
electricity producing wind turbine;
ultra high-efficiency wood stove;
structural frame constructed of engineered parallam wood timbers and long-span roof trusses;
Originally published in the Globe and Mail on Oct. 29th, 2009
Architect Paul Dowsett wraps up our tour of a fantastic Bluffs-area renovation/rebuild with an apology: "I'm finding these interviews harder because all of this stuff comes so naturally to me I keep thinking I'll forget something," he says with a laugh.
The "stuff" in question is sustainable, Mr. Dowsett's stock-and-trade. In this re-imagining of a small, one-storey bungalow on Scarborough's Brooklawn Ave. into a two-storey, medium-sized home, the architect has implemented many features found at his own residence (featured here this past June) such as New Brunswick-made argon-filled wood windows, radiant floors and a highly reflective Galvalume roof with a solar panel to heat the hot water supply.
Homeowners Margaret and Peter Kristensen, however, are reminded every day that the environmentally responsible choices they've made were the right ones. "It's just so comfortable and the air is so nice," says Ms. Kristensen.
It ought to be. In the basement utility room is the heat recovery ventilator, which expels stale internal air for fresh, but not before it extracts existing heat. Nearby, the many home automation units that control lighting, heating, music and security allow the homeowners to interact with the home from anywhere in the world via computer. With a nod to future legislation, there's a sprinkler system but, unlike the old type that holds rusty water in the pipes, this one is constantly refreshed every time a tap is turned on.
Yes, parts of this project are complicated, but others were a no-brainer, like location and design. The Kristensens purchased the tidy little home in 1972 and raised a family here, but, as empty nesters, found the many extended family get-togethers were difficult to shoehorn in; since they loved the area, the solution was to expand.
However, they'd already decided to buck the neighbourhood trend of teardown-and-replace with a "cookie-cutter" builder's home in favour of something "different." The couple had seen Mr. Dowsett's work (then a principal at Scott Morris Architects, now owner of sustainABLE) and thought, rightly so, that he'd be capable of a renovation/reconstruction that blended in with the existing mid-twentieth-century housing stock while also being a product of the early twenty-first.
"You start not knowing what you want; it was really Paul who influenced the style of the house because he knew we wanted to stay sympathetic to the area," remembers Ms. Kristensen. "It's a very emotional thing when you do this."
So, keeping emotion and context in mind, Mr. Dowsett looked to Atomic Ranch magazine--which celebrates the humble 1950s ranch style aesthetic--for inspiration rather than his own 1915 green reno near Danforth and Jones avenues. He found it in a 1953 development of L-shaped plans in Lincoln, Nebraska called "The Trend Homes" by Strauss Brothers Company.
"So you get these rooms where you get light from three sides, and that's happening in all parts of the house," he explains. Most renovators, he adds, would just "tack a big projecting box" onto the back of the home without considering light penetration or the way the sun affects enjoyment of the patio. By creating an L-shape, the patio slid into the space where the two sections meet: "At noon, in the high summer sun, [the patio] will be in shade, which is more important, and then in the evening when the sun is over there," he points to the sky, "there gets to be some sunshine at dinner time."
Inside, evidence of this simple technique for harnessing light abounds. In the foyer, light from the frosted glass door and big window shakes hands with photons pouring into the long window over the sink in the fire engine red galley kitchen, which melts into more light along the living room wall; finally, the west-facing living room windows at the back of the house pick up the slack. In the dining room--now big enough to hold over 20 diners if need be--there is light on three sides also.
Upstairs, light penetrates from opening skylights (which close automatically when it rains) and additional large windows. As a bonus, the long strip window over the bed frames a new view of Lake Ontario. High, peaked ceilings with fans keep warm air pushed down.
In addition to things sustainable, Mr. Dowsett's design includes things sensitive to the homeowner's personal needs, such as the three fireplaces and a two-person steam shower in the ensuite. A small powder room on the main floor near the dining area has an antechamber that provides storage and peace of mind for guests: "A big thing of mine is that you shouldn't go out of the powder room directly back into the party; you've got a little bit of time to get yourself back together before you're back to the dining room," he explains. The street façade pays tribute to the original design via a front porch that carves away the south corner. "It was a big hit with the neighbours that we kept that porch," says Ms. Kristensen.
Overall, this is a house that both pays tribute to what was once there yet doesn't cram in features that "push it out of the market of its neighbourhood," says Mr. Dowsett. "I think that more renovations should be done like this in these midcentury neighbourhoods.
"Sensible plus sensitive equals sustainable," he finishes. "It's almost an equation."
Re-imagining a small, one-storey mid-20th century bungalow near the Scarborough Bluffs into a two-storey, medium-sized 21st century home. This renovation/reconstruction blends in with the existing mid-twentieth-century housing stock while also being a product of the early twenty-first. This house that pays tribute to what was once there and yet doesn't cram in features that push it out of the market of its neighbourhood.
Architect: Scott Morris Architects Inc.
Principal in Charge: Paul Dowsett, Architect
Sustainable features include:
New Brunswick-made argon-filled wood windows;
hydronic radiant floor heating;
highly-reflective (high albedo) galvalume roof;
solar panel to pre-heat the incoming water supply; and
home automation to control lighting, heating, music and security.
Originally published in the Globe and Mail on July 8th, 2010
Architect Paul Dowsett and developer David Daniels have finished gutting Mr. Daniel's 1939 art deco mansion. The result is a masterpiece of green building.
When Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers whirled across the silver screen, it looked effortless: visual milk and honey. But it took an army to fabricate that Jazz Age cocktail, from costumers, makeup artists and lighting technicians to set designers, camera operators and, of course, the choreographer and director. And that's to say nothing of the foot-cramping rehearsals the famous dancing duo had to endure. Good thing they rolled credits.
In architecture, it's different. Often, only the client's and the architect's names are bandied about when discussing a project, which is a shame. As architect Paul Dowsett will tell you, projects the size and scope of David and Kate Daniels's "eco-deco" mansion in the Toronto neighbourhood of South Hill require the collective brainpower of dozens and dozens.
I'd list them all if I could. But that would mean I'd have no room for Act III, which completes the story of how this amazing 1935 buff-brick beauty, designed by architect Mackenzie Waters for major-general Donald M. Hogarth, has been restored and reimagined as a showcase of sustainable technology.
I first toured the 8,000-square-foot home in November, 2007. Even then, as I walked through empty rooms and noted little more than newly installed, double-glazed, low-emission windows with light shelves, the project was already over two years old, as preliminary sketches had been done in April, 2005.
In June, 2008, I checked the progress that Mr. Dowsett, then a principal at Scott Morris Architects, and project manager Nick Egizii had made. As usual, we marvelled at some of the home's original details, such as the domed foyer ceiling, the Gloria Swanson-esque sweeping staircase and the sprung-floor basement ballroom, while discussing in greater detail the green thinking and new technologies being showcased.
These included:
Reuse and recycle where possible. Original steel windows will become interior closet doors; wood from the original interior sauna will clad the exterior pool house.
High-albedo paint on the roof deflects the sun's rays; to supply hot water, an array of solar panels has been installed.
In new additions such as the bump-out, glass-walled kitchen, floors from Granular Hardwood Technologies that look like terrazzo but consist of crushed walnut shells have been poured.
A huge mechanical room underneath the kitchen - which Mr. Dowsett compares to the engine room of a "Nimitz-class submarine" - is where everything from backup boilers and solar-panel readouts to the geothermal system are stacked up in a "three-dimensional game of Tetris."
Now, while touring the final, furnished product, it's easy to forget all of that, and the cast of characters who put it together, as the eye is drawn to the exquisite collection of furniture, lighting and art, some of it a reflection of Mr. Daniels's sense of humour. There's the fake, backlit commercial sign by Vancouver's Ken Lum in a hallway; the glass case surrounding the living-room fireplace (Mr. Daniels, who has owned retail stores in the past, says this is called a "glorifier" in the business); custom millwork in the kitchen has cut-out pulls inspired "by looking at Paul Klee and Kandinsky"; and, finally, the egg-shaped bathtub in the master en suite is a touch of sculptural whimsy.
Just as a Jazz Age skyscraper economically concentrates architectural detailing on the first few floors and then again at its crown (why waste it on the middle part that no one sees?), baseboards and trim are dressed in deco details only where the eye rests.
Outside, near the pool, two hedges are cut into a question mark and an exclamation point, which Mr. Daniels suggests is a sort of personal motto: "For me, that's how you have to look at life - all of life should be questions and surprises."
Now that the question of whether this already impressive home could be transformed into a showcase of sustainability as the eco-deco mansion has been answered, it's time for surprises. One came just a few months after the family moved in, when the gas company called to say there must be a faulty meter at the house since it was showing zero activity. Mr. Daniels had to explain, gently, that he had switched to a geothermal system. Another is how low-tech "green" features are performing beyond expectations - for example, the light shelves bring so much light into the home so late into the day that turning on artificial lights is delayed significantly. "This is largely an exercise in light," Mr. Daniels says of the project.
It is also, as stated earlier, an exercise in collaboration: "At the first meeting, I said, 'I want to see your Grade 4 report card because I want to see if the teacher checked off 'Plays Well With Others,' " Mr. Dowsett laughs.
And while Mr. Daniels and Mr. Dowsett probably have more in common with Bing Crosby and Bob Hope than with Astaire and Rogers, they are indeed entering into a partnership as a result of the success of the project. Sustainable.TO will be a "one-stop shop for all things sustainable" offering consultation, design and construction for places as large as the eco-deco mansion or as small as a modest suburban bungalow.
Originally published in the Globe and Mail on Nov 30th, 2007
Standing beside the newly-poured concrete lap pool with my back to the spreading city parceled in grids below, I don't need to squint at David Daniels' new home to see it: clearly, it is a mini-Maple Leaf Gardens.
Built on a promontory in the neighbourhood now known as South Hill for Major General Donald M. Hogarth, an MPP who later became a mining magnate, the 8,000 square foot house was designed by Toronto-based architect Mackenzie Waters in 1935. Four years before, Mr. Waters had worked as associate architect with Montreal firm Ross & Macdonald on the much beloved hockey shrine, and it's obvious that he took something away from that experience. Pointing to the restrained rhythmic façade and buff brick banding that smacks of its cousin on Carlton St., Mr. Daniels remarks: "I call this whole project 'The Echo of Deco.'"
"Is that 'echo' with an 'h'?" asks architect Paul Dowsett cheekily, referring to the extensive list of eco-friendly and sustainable technologies his firm, Scott Morris Architects, is incorporating into the renovation and expansion of this historic mansion.
There is a duality to the project. Firstly, Mr. Daniels's team--which in addition to Mr. Dowsett includes project manager Nick Egizii, landscape architect Ron Holbrook, interior designer Phillip Moody and Simon Boone of Generation Solar--will be restoring as many of the home's art deco features as possible, such as the domed foyer ceiling, the sweeping terrazzo staircase and the amazing sprung-floor ballroom in the basement. "I'm fanatically devoted to Toronto and to preserving what we can of the housing stock," explains Mr. Daniels, a self-confessed heritage lover. Reconsidering, he corrects himself: "Preserving is not the right word because this is not a preservation, this is a re-imagining of something but trying to respect as much of what the original building has to offer." Since the home's deco features seem to stop somewhere past the foyer (perhaps due to a case of original owner cold feet), Mr. Daniels is "re-imagining" what might have been and installing deco trim, moulding and other finishes throughout.
Secondly, as many sustainable features as eco-expert Mr. Dowsett can dream up are being incorporated into the home, which currently sits stripped down to the studs on the inside and, on the outside, is shamelessly flashing its raw steel skeleton at the next-door neighbours to the east. As we walk the perimeter on a sunny November Sunday, most obvious are the new double-glazed, low-E aluminum windows with their accompanying sunshades, designed to prevent overheating interiors in summer yet allow the low-flying winter sun to penetrate unimpeded. On the inside, "light shelves" will reflect sunlight onto the ceiling, says Mr. Dowsett, "so that we'll be penetrating natural daylight as far into the house as possible, reducing the need to turn on electric lights." Mr. Daniels adds: "What I like about this [technology] is that it's completely low-tech--it's just a matter of doing your calculations."
Rather than sending the old, inefficient single-pane windows to landfill, they'll soon enjoy a new life as interior design elements in the form of cabinet or closet doors. "If we can recycle it...we'll reuse it on this site, if we can reuse it on a neighbours property, we'll do that," explains Mr. Dowsett, pointing to the pool house, which is being framed with wood salvaged from the demolition of the original third floor.
And speaking of the third floor, where there was once an inset, mansard-roofed servant's quarters there now sits a sparkling new Miesian triple-glazed box which will eventually be surrounded by the second floor green roof. The third floor has a "high albedo" roof: highly reflective white paint deflects sunlight and reduces the need for cooling in summer. On top of the porte-cochere, another original structure, a potter's shed, has been removed and will eventually be replaced by a similar glass box connected by a bridge; the aforementioned east addition will soon be ready for its glass enclosure. Like the aluminum windows, these additions are meant to stand in stark contrast to the original dwelling in an effort to distinguish what's old from what's new.
There are plenty of new things that can't be seen with the naked eye. Interesting is the use of concrete that uses fifty per cent less cement by replacing it with industrial waste-products fly ash and slag (this is good because for each measure of regular cement replaced with a supplementary bonding material, that same measure is saved in CO2 emissions) and, where new flooring is being installed (much of the home's original wood floors are being preserved), a new, locally produced product by Granular Hardwood Technologies simulating the look of terrazzo using waste walnut shells as the aggregate, is being employed. "It was one of the neatest products that turned up in our research," offers Mr. Daniels.
As we walk from bare room to bare room stepping over construction equipment or manoeuvring around his yet-to-be installed heat pumps, I ask Mr. Daniels why the commitment to "green" technologies. He answers, simply, that it's something he's "carried around for a very long time.
"I tried to do it twice before and it was completely unaffordable and the technology was so rudimentary I just couldn't get there." Third time's a charm, and with geothermal heating, rainwater collection and solar initiatives, he's getting there big time.
He's also going out of his way to save a significant piece of Toronto's architectural heritage. Perhaps that's because he grew up surrounded by a love of architecture; his father, John Daniels, Chairman of the Daniels Corporation, is a legendary figure who is responsible for much of what is good, architecturally, about this city. "Any sensibility I have about this stuff came from my family," he confirms.
Combining restoration, cutting-edge environmental and an amazing collaboration between architect and client (Mr. Dowsett is an avowed art deco fan and has been boning up on his viewings of 1930s movies for inspiration), this is such an exciting project I've asked Mr. Daniels if I can return a few more times to see the progress and, thankfully, he's agreed.
"I can't wait to see it when it's done," I tell him.
"You're not the only one," he finishes with a laugh.
Photos by George Opreff & Paul Dowsett, hover over an image for attribution.
Back at the Eco Deco Mansion
Originally published in the Globe and Mail on June 27th, 2009
The thing about massive renovation projects is that they always look their worst just before they start to look better.
With that in mind, I visited for the second time the future home of David Daniels--once the home of Major General Donald M. Hogarth--after first reporting on the project in November 2007. Designed by Toronto architect Mackenzie Waters in 1935, the 8,000 square foot, sturdy art deco brick box is slowly, methodically being brought into the twenty-first century--spatially, sustainably and otherwise--by architect and green-expert Paul Dowsett of Scott Morris Architects.
Punctuated by the squeal of power saws, our tour began just outside the home's formal front door, where deliveries were occurring so frequently a turnstile might be more appropriate. Here, in the wall of the porte-cochere, a large, original metal window has been installed for decorative purposes rather than being sent to landfill; surrounding brick has been salvaged from other areas of the house and the colour and texture of the new mortar has been painstakingly matched.
On the porte-cochere's roof, where once there stood a dilapidated old potter's shed, a modern, glassy guesthouse now sits, which connects to the main house by an equally modern umbilical cord of a bridge. "It was one of the first conceits when we first started talking about the house," says Mr. Daniels about the bridge idea, "and it's actually come true, out of all the crazy ideas that I've had throughout the last few years, and I think it's better than I imagined it."
In a way, the porte-cochere can be seen as a microcosm of the entire project: Old parts have been salvaged and repurposed; efforts have been made to duplicate original work; and there is the marriage of old and new architecture.
In the backyard, stacks and stacks of cedar from a demolished sauna await new life as partition walls in the pool house. Underfoot is a rich, creamy "Algonquin stone" from Owen Sound--"as local as we could get," chuckles the architect--that will spill out into the rest of the yard; above our heads is the new, pre-patina'd copper flashing with a folded "three-part detail" to echo the banded (and very deco) lines of the brickwork.
Despite the construction storm before the calm, there is much to see inside the house. Mr. Dowsett is conducting tests of art deco moulding styles for the ceiling, because, as he puts it, "in drawing you can only do so much." The jury is still out on whether these will feature curves, hard angles or a combination of both.
The entire "east wing" addition has now been clad in the high-tech, triple-glazed pale green curtain wall that adorns the other modern additions (in my first report this wing was just a skeleton), and it is here that I got my first glimpse of the much-ballyhooed walnut shell flooring by Granular Hardwood Technologies, which simulates the look of expensive terrazzo by using waste walnut shell pieces as the aggregate after they've been used to clean jet engines. Here, too, in what will become a chef's delight of a kitchen is another interesting feature: a remotely activated, large sliding glass door--not unlike the kind at the local grocery store--that Mr. Daniels predicts will become the home's principal entrance. "I think your family is going to live in this room," confirms Mr. Dowsett. "This is the view, it's just stunning"
Not only is the view stunning, so is the performance. The curtain wall system has proven so effective an insulator, an earlier plan to install solar blinds has been scrapped. "Some of this stuff actually works," laughs Mr. Daniels. "As a consumer, you're inundated with it every day now; every day you turn on the TV, you pick up a newspaper or magazine and all you hear about is this green material, that green material, and thank god some of it works!"
Upstairs, awaiting refinishing are original hardwood floors that have been 'patched' with pieces from other areas. Cuts to this three-quarter-century-old wood were done so precisely, says project manager Nick Egizii, the flooring contractors said it was "easier working with this than working with new wood." Reflective "high albedo" paint isn't the only thing covering the roof this time. Lined up like a giant's fallen dominos are massive solar panels that will supply the home with its entire hot water supply. Not only that, says Mr. Dowsett, they do "double-duty" by helping to shade the roof. Popping up here and there are electrical "goosenecks" that will eventually connect to solar-electric panels: "At one point in time, we imagine that it will be cost effective to install solar-electric," says Mr. Daniels.
Until then, green pioneer Mr. Daniels is having a blast doing nightly research into sustainable technologies with a low-cost/high-benefit ratio, and Mr. Dowsett and Mr. Egizii are busily making it all happen.
And I, your humble Architourist (who can see past the mess) will bring you the finished project sometime in late 2008 or early 2009. "We're as on schedule as you can be in a renovation," finishes Mr. Daniels.
Combining restoration, re-imagination, and cutting-edge environmental technologies, the Daniels' Residence demonstrates an amazing collaboration between architect, contractor, and client going out of their way to save a significant piece of Toronto's heritage.
We respected as much of what the original 1935-era building had to offer while restoring many of its original Art Deco features, and updating the house through sensitive & sensible renovations and additions.
Architect: Scott Morris Architects Inc.
Principal in Charge: Paul Dowsett, Architect
Prominent sustainable practices and technologies include:
geothermal heating and cooling; solar water heating;
Originally published in the Globe and Mail on June 12, 2009
"Greens are good for you." "Save your pennies." "Don't run with scissors."
All that nagging was enough to make you hop on your Green Machine (by Marx Toys and way cooler than the Big Wheel) and ride off to join the circus. Too bad all that broccoli weighed you down.
But 1970s moms were wise. So too is twenty-first century architect Paul Dowsett: He agrees that green is good for you and, should you decide to embrace sustainability as a way of life, he can save you a lot of pennies.
You might say Mr. Dowsett, 47, is a green machine. From the greening of mega-institutions, schools and commercial buildings to the reworking of an 8,000 square foot 1935 art deco home into an Eco-Deco showplace for Mr. David Daniels (featured in this space twice), he's doing the big money stuff, with LEED accreditation to back him up (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design).
His own 1915 home in the Danforth and Jones neighbourhood known affectionately as "the Pocket" is an example, however, of how to go green without going broke.
"Everything here is inexpensive because I have a very tight budget," he laughs.
Starting at the top, literally, is the Galvalume roof. While the aluminum-zinc alloy coated sheet metal costs twice as much as asphalt shingles, the material has a 50-year lifespan that's been proven in the salty wet Maritimes. It can be installed "right out of the factory" by any roofing contractor, meaning installation costs are comparable. Green-wise, the fluted shape allows hot air to travel up and vent away before heating the attic, and the highly reflective surface acts in much the same way as the high-albedo paint used on Mr. Daniel's residence.
Hot water is generated by a roof-mounted solar panel. Heat collected at the panel travels in a glycol solution to the mechanical room to warm cold municipal water via a heat exchanger, then it's stored in a tank. When hot water is needed for the old radiators, the new radiant floors (in the addition) or faucets, it travels through a tankless water heater, where an extra heat-boost is applied if needed.
Wide steps of Brazilian ipe wood (also known as "iron wood" because of its durability) leading up to the columned front porch--a nod to the Texas birthplace of Mr. Dowsett's partner--fool the eye into thinking the narrow 16-foot home is much wider. When purchased in 1997, six rooms were crammed into the 400-square foot main floor; today, it's an open concept dining room and kitchen area, and the living room now occupies a seamless 2005 addition Mr. Dowsett tacked onto the back.
Well, it would be seamless were it not for the light-well/courtyard. This cheap and cheerful feature, which gives a clue as to where the original house once ended, brings much-needed southern light into the middle of the home, which allows for passive solar heating. It also positions the double-gazed, low-E, argon-gas filled wood-frame windows across from one another so that, when opened, air circulation is improved. It's a little gesture, but it achieves much: "There are maybe three or four evenings a year that are uncomfortable," says the architect.
Upstairs, notable in the front room is the high ceiling, which Mr. Dowsett and partner Ron Lambert reinforced with scissor-trusses so it could be peaked (it was a flat, low ceiling) and a ceiling fan installed. Interestingly, although Mr. Dowsett has no plans to sell, the master bedroom facing the back garden has been designed with symmetrical closets and big windows on either side so that, should a larger family move in one day, the room could be easily split into two children's bedrooms.
Not only has the couple reduced their energy use, they also practice reuse and recycling: Original, ornate radiators were stripped and repainted at an autobody shop, the iron railing cradling the sexy staircase comes from Mr. Dowsett's childhood home, there is gently used mid-century modern furniture here and there, and the brick pavers in the backyard were once the back wall and chimney of the house before being removed for the addition.
The home is not a techno-geek paradise of wind towers, storage batteries and geo-thermal heating, yet, with a "series of small choices" Mr. Dowsett has maintained the same amount of energy use while almost doubling the living space.
He enjoys making green choices so much, he wants to help others with theirs. After over two decades at big firms, he'll be hanging his own shingle, sustainABLE, in the "green-collar" Leslieville neighbourhood in the next few months: "Average people are probably intimidated by a large firm, they don't want to pay those fees...and I know that there are a lot of houses in this city that are in the mid-range of 300 to 500 thousand dollars," he says. "All of those people, if you asked them, would want to do the most environmentally responsible thing, they just don't know where to start."
By improving one of the most dilapidated houses in the neighbourhood, and following some very basic principles of sustainability and urbanism, this house strives to be as "green" as resources will allow. In using the resources that are already there, this house optimizes what exists, rather than using more and more.
Architect: Scott Morris Architects Inc.
Principal in Charge: Paul Dowsett, Architect
Sustainable strategies utilized include:
reinstating the front porch and gallery at "conversation distance" from the sidewalk;
use of a neighbourhood contractor;
high albedo, locally-manufactured galvalume roof;
modern, flexible, open-plan living spaces;
a central courtyard to allow natural daylight and breezes to penetrate deep into the house;
use of efficient double-glazed windows and window placement;
existing and new native deciduous trees and vines;
a solar water heater to pre-heat incoming water;
high second-floor ceilings with reversible ceiling fans; and
wood framing instead of steel framing, chosen for wood's lower embodied energy.
This 1960 Better Homes and Gardens Idea House is highly practical and liveable, with simultaneous feelings of lightness and seclusion. In order to meet the needs of a 21st century Toronto family and to optimize the existing qualities of the house, it was a simple matter to enclose the front screened entry courtyard to create a front entry vestibule with coat closets and a boot bench. The wall between this new indoor space and the existing living room was replaced wait a semi-permeable display shelf, maintaining the original lightness and seclusion. A dining room addition was also designed behind the kitchen, with access to a future pool deck and cabana. These pieces have yet to be realized. All modifications, completed and proposed, maintain the long low proportion of this mid-century modern family home.
Photos by George Opreff, hover over or zoom an image for attribution.
Alterations to a 1960 Better Homes and Gardens Idea House
to meet the needs of a 21st century Toronto family and to optimize the existing qualities of the house, maintaining the original qualities of lightness and seclusion.
Thank you to you and your team for creating a beautiful kitchen for me. I am very happy with the huge change you made in my small space and how functional the design is. A would -be gourmet cook, I am so pleased with how everything turned out and now enjoy spending time in my kitchen.
All of Bev's design choices came together just beautifully, and as I have told you the "talk through' you designed has changed the whole dynamic of my home.
Your whole team was extremely professional and responsive to my needs and wants and I would be happy to recommend you to my friends and family.
Warmest Regards,
Sylvia
This sensible & sensitive renovation, links the new kitchen to the rest of the house through a new "talk thru window." This modern kitchen makeover is an example of how a small space can make a huge change to a home by introducing functionality and efficiency to the design. As the modern centre for meeting and social interaction, a new integrated kitchen in an old space can change the whole dynamic of a house.
Prepared by E.R.A. Architects, planningAlliance, and the Cities Centre at the University of Toronto for the Ontario Growth Secretariat Ministry of Infrastructure